10-Point ETF Checklist for Canadian Investors

10-Point ETF Checklist for Canadian Investors

Exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, can make diversification easier. However, the ETF label does not guarantee that a fund is safe, suitable, or low risk.

Two ETFs with similar names may hold very different investments. They may charge different fees, produce income in different ways, or expose investors to different levels of sector, currency, and market risk.

That is why ETF due diligence should begin before you look at recent returns.

This 10-point ETF checklist is designed for Canadian investors who want steady, long-term results and prefer to understand what they own before committing capital.

1. Understand What the ETF Is Designed to Do

Start by identifying the fund’s objective. What result is the ETF trying to produce, and how does it plan to achieve it?

Some ETFs track an index. Others use an active strategy in which a manager selects or adjusts investments. The fund may focus on growth, income, capital preservation, or a mix of these goals.

You should also determine whether the ETF offers broad exposure or focuses on one sector, theme, country, or asset class.

Do not rely on the fund’s name. Read the ETF Facts document and the provider’s fund overview before reviewing performance. The fund’s official documents should explain its strategy, benchmark, fees, risks, and major holdings.

2. Check What the ETF Actually Owns

Next, examine the underlying portfolio.

Review the ETF’s top 10 holdings, total number of holdings, sector weights, geographic exposure, and asset-class mix. For bond ETFs, also review credit quality, maturity, and sensitivity to interest-rate changes.

Pay attention to concentration. An ETF may own 100 securities but still depend heavily on a small number of companies.

For example, if the top 10 holdings make up a large part of the fund, the ETF may be less diversified than its total number of holdings suggests.

The best ETF criteria are not simply “more holdings” or “higher yield.” The important question is whether the fund gives you the exposure you expect.

3. Look for Overlap With Existing Investments

Owning several ETFs does not always create better diversification.

Suppose you already own a broad Canadian equity ETF and then add a Canadian dividend ETF. Both funds may hold large positions in the same banks, pipelines, telecommunications companies, and energy producers.

You now own two ETFs, but your portfolio may be more concentrated than it appears.

A similar issue can occur when combining an S&P 500 ETF with a U.S. technology ETF. Many of the technology fund’s largest companies may already be major holdings in the broader index.

Compare the top holdings and sector weights of a potential ETF with the investments you already own. The goal is to determine whether the new fund adds useful exposure or simply duplicates existing positions.

4. Review the MER and Other Costs

The management expense ratio, or MER, is the percentage of a fund’s assets used each year to pay management fees and operating expenses. These costs reduce investor returns.

When comparing ETF fees in Canada, look beyond the MER.

Consider:

• Trading commissions

• Bid-ask spreads

• Currency-conversion charges

• Possible tax costs in non-registered accounts

A difference of a few tenths of a percentage point may seem small, but recurring fees can have a meaningful effect over many years.

However, the lowest-fee ETF is not automatically the best choice. A cheaper fund may have poor liquidity, excessive concentration, or a strategy that does not fit your needs.

Cost matters, but suitability matters more.

5. Examine Fund Size and Liquidity

Liquidity affects how easily you can buy or sell an ETF at a reasonable price.

Review the fund’s assets under management, average daily trading volume, and bid-ask spread. A narrow bid-ask spread generally means lower trading costs, while a wider spread can increase the price you pay or reduce the amount you receive.

The liquidity of the underlying holdings also matters. An ETF that owns large, actively traded companies may be easier to trade than one holding small companies, specialized bonds, or less liquid assets.

Consider using limit orders instead of market orders, especially for thinly traded ETFs or during volatile markets. A limit order lets you set the maximum price you will pay or the minimum price you will accept.

6. Evaluate the Distribution Yield Carefully

A high distribution yield may look attractive, especially for investors seeking retirement income. However, yield alone does not show whether the ETF is producing a sustainable return.

ETF distributions may come from dividends, bond interest, capital gains, return of capital, or income from options strategies.

Review where the distributions come from and whether they have been stable. Also check whether they are paid monthly, quarterly, annually, or irregularly.

Most importantly, compare the distribution yield with total return. A fund can pay a large distribution while its unit price declines.

A high payout does not protect the market value of your investment.

7. Understand the Main Risks

A proper ETF risk assessment asks one basic question: What could cause this fund to lose value?

Depending on the strategy, the main risks may include:

• Equity-market risk

• Interest-rate risk

• Credit risk

• Currency risk

• Sector concentration

• Use of leverage or derivatives

Pay extra attention to leveraged, inverse, highly thematic, and narrowly concentrated ETFs. These products can behave very differently from broad-market funds and may require close monitoring.

Covered-call ETFs also deserve careful review. Their option income may support larger distributions, but the strategy can limit participation when markets rise strongly.

Do not buy an ETF unless you can explain its main risks in plain language.

8. Check Currency Exposure and Hedging

Canadian investors may face currency risk even when buying an ETF on a Canadian exchange.

A Canadian-listed ETF may still hold U.S. or international securities. If the fund is unhedged, movements in the Canadian dollar can increase or reduce your return.

For example, foreign stocks may rise while the Canadian dollar strengthens. When the investment is converted back into Canadian dollars, your gain may be smaller.

Currency-hedged ETFs attempt to reduce the effect of exchange-rate changes. Hedging is not automatically better or worse. It adds costs and may help or hurt returns depending on currency movements.

Also consider foreign-exchange conversion charges when buying U.S.-listed ETFs in U.S. dollars.

9. Consider the Best Account for the ETF

The account holding an ETF can affect taxes and income.

Common account types include a Tax-Free Savings Account, or TFSA, a Registered Retirement Savings Plan, or RRSP, a Registered Retirement Income Fund, or RRIF, and a non-registered account.

Interest, Canadian dividends, foreign income, capital gains, and return of capital may receive different tax treatment.

Foreign withholding tax may also apply to some distributions, including dividends from U.S. and international holdings. The result can depend on the ETF’s structure, what it owns, where it is listed, and which account holds it.

Account placement should reflect the fund’s holdings, income type, your time horizon, and your wider tax situation.

10. Decide What Role the ETF Will Play

Before buying, write down the job the ETF will perform in your portfolio.

Will it be a core holding or a smaller satellite position? Is it meant to provide growth, income, bonds, international diversification, or cash-like exposure?

Set a target portfolio percentage. Also decide when you will rebalance and what conditions might justify selling.

Valid reasons to sell may include a strategy change, higher costs, poor index tracking, a change in your goals, or the ETF no longer serving its intended purpose.

Strong recent performance is not a portfolio role. Writing down your reason for buying can help reduce impulse decisions and performance chasing.

Before You Buy an ETF, Know What You Own

Learning how to choose an ETF involves more than comparing fees, yields, and past returns.

A low-cost fund may still be unsuitable if it duplicates existing holdings, creates too much concentration, or does not match your goals.

Before placing your next ETF order, work through all 10 questions. A few minutes of due diligence can help you avoid unnecessary costs, duplicated holdings, and risks that do not belong in your long-term plan.

Save or print this ETF checklist and use it each time you research a new fund.

This article is for general educational purposes only. It does not provide personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. ETF risks and tax consequences vary by product and investor.

A professional investment analyst for more than 30 years, Pat has developed a stock-selection technique that has proven reliable in both bull and bear markets. His proprietary ValuVesting System™ focuses on stocks that provide exceptional quality at relatively low prices. Many savvy investors and industry leaders consider it the most powerful stock-picking method ever created.