How Successful Investors Get RICH

Learn everything you need to know in 'The Canadian Guide on How to Invest in Stocks Successfully' for FREE from The Successful Investor.

How to Invest In Stocks Guide: Find 10 factors that make your investments safer and stronger.

Topic: Daily Advice

Investor Toolkit: The big difference between bottom-up and top-down investing

Stock Market

Every Wednesday, we publish our “Investor Toolkit” series on TSI Network. Whether you’re a beginning or experienced investor, these weekly updates are designed to give you specific investment tips and stock market advice. Each Investor Toolkit update gives you a fundamental piece of investment advice, and shows you how you can put it into practice right away.

Today’s tip: “Bottom-up investors have the great advantage of basing their decisions on what they know about stocks, rather than trying to guess how stocks might be affected by a random series of events.”

In the early chapters of any good book on fundamental stock market advice, you will come across the two basic ways to make investment decisions: bottom-up and top-down.

Using the bottom-up approach, you focus on understanding what’s going on, rather than trying to predict what happens next. You could call this descriptive finance. You delve into earnings, dividends, sales, balance sheet structure, competitive advantages and so on.

From there, it quickly becomes obvious that there’s an awful lot you don’t know about the risks in the investments you are considering. So you try to design a portfolio in which the risks offset each other.

Using the top-down approach (which you might call predictive finance), you downplay what’s going on now and try to figure out what happens next. You may zero in on trends in stock prices, the economy, interest rates, gold and so on. You may disregard most details. Or, you may focus on a single key trend, event or detail, such as the Y2K scare that gripped the world in late 1999, the Internet stock boom of the same era, avian flu, or the future of the electric car.

In any one year, top investment honours often go to a top-down advisor. When enough people offer opinions about the future, after all, somebody has to get it right. But nobody gets it right every time. Anybody who did would eventually acquire a measurable share of all the money in the world, and nobody ever does that.

That’s why there’s a lot of turnover in the top ranks of top-down investors. One bad guess can ruin a previously enviable record.

Hidden value in plain sight

Pat McKeough puts a premium on safety in The Successful Investor—and seeks out the hidden value that brings spectacular gains. He finds value where many others fail to look—right out in plain sight in well-established dividend stocks. Like the real estate assets whose value Canadian Tire and Loblaw unlocked when it spun those assets into REITs. Or the undervalued assets of CP Rail that caused that stock to soar—over 70% in a year—when Pat made it his Canadian Stock of the Year.

As a new subscriber you can benefit immediately with a $50.00 saving off the regular price. You also get free updates and advice every week in the Successful Investor Email/Telephone Hotline. Click here to take advantage of this special offer right away.

Stock market advice: Gains add up for bottom-up investors

Over periods of five years and beyond, however, top investment honours mostly go to a member of the bottom-up crowd. That’s partly because bottom-uppers tend to make fewer big mistakes. This lets their gains accumulate. This also leads to longer holding periods, which provide greater tax deferral and lower brokerage costs.

The top-down approach appeals to beginning investors, when they have not yet learned how little they know. (That’s a good time for it, when you have little money to invest and can’t do yourself much harm.) By the time they build up enough of a stake to begin serious investing, most advisors and investors have settled on a mix of top-down and bottom-up. As years pass, successful investors tend to put more weight on bottom-up. They like the way it cuts risk.

Sometimes, a top-down idea acquires way too much influence on way too many investors. A classic example was the intense interest that built up for many months in 2012 over Greece’s debt crisis and a possible eurozone economic collapse, if not a worldwide collapse. Week after week, in almost every newspaper or online news source you could find one or more articles delving into how that might occur, and the devastating financial results that would follow.

This widespread attention tends to get priced into the market, as traders say. In other words, investors react to this kind of potential calamity by paying a little less for investments than they otherwise would. As a result, you can buy good investments for less money.

At the height of the eurozone crisis, European authorities crept tentatively, and often nervously, towards a final resolution of the fiscal predicament in Greece. As they did so, the markets adjusted and even moved up. The predicted collapse did not occur.

To put it another way, if the risk of another European debt crisis—or the future of oil prices, or ongoing unrest in the Middle East—tempts you to sell all your stocks and go into cash (as traders say), keep one thing in mind: you’re not the only person who knows about that risk.

Coming up Next

Tomorrow in our post on the U.S. stock market we look at the one stock that may be getting the most out of online shopping.


Tell Us What YOU Think

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Please be respectful with your comments and help us keep this an area that everyone can enjoy. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Terms of Use, please click here to report it to the administrator.