Three ETFs—two buys and one we don’t like

Article Excerpt

Here’s a look at three popular ETFs in three different areas—medical-device makers, natural resource producers and S&P 500 companies (but with a twist). We like the first two, but we think the third is likely to underperform its “plain vanilla” counterpart. Meanwhile, the Supplement on page 10 provides more information on the three investment areas. ISHARES US MEDICAL DEVICES ETF $50.47 (New York symbol IHI; TSINetwork ETF Rating: Aggressive; Market cap: $5.0 billion) invests in U.S. companies involved in the medical device industry. They include manufacturers and distributors of medical devices such as MRI scanners, prosthetics, X-ray machines, and other non-disposable medical devices. Stocks are weighted based on their market values. The ETF currently holds 54 stocks of which the top 10 contribute 73% of total assets. The top holdings are Abbott Laboratories (17.8%), Intuitive Surgical (10.7%), Medtronic (10.3%), Stryker (7.4%), Boston Scientific (4.9%), Becton Dickenson (4.5%), DexCom (4.5%), Idexx Laboratories (4.5%), Edwards Lifesciences (4.2%) and GE HealthCare Technologies (3.9%). The fund has a large asset…